a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray

In Franks film, Pete is saddled with guilt because he feels somewhat responsible for Franceys death, made even worse because he was in love with her. Privacy Policy Drake, Usher, and Burna Boy to Headline J. Coles Dreamville Festival. Read our extensive list of rules for more information on other types of posts like fan-art and self-promotion, or message the moderators if you have any questions. Firstly, there is no shootout in the graveyard, a sequence which seems invented purely for the sake of putting action on the screen. Albert suddenly tries to strangle him from behind with a metal wire. Purchase A Walk Among the Tombstones on digital and stream instantly or download offline. Hence why the former killed the latter, because he had gotten what he wanted and didn't like the dude. The green screen at the end was pretty bad, though. Another guy is plugged in the leg and torso. A Walk Among The Tombstones'movie finale sees Scudder and Kenny tracking down kidnapper Albert after the gunfight, with the latter having killed wounded partner Ray. He goes into the basement where he finds Rays body and tools used for dismembering bodies. And so, with the official movie tie-in book landing on our doorstep, we figured it was a good opportunity to investigate how the source material and movie were aligned and where changes were made, and how these choices affected the movie. TJ helps with the research. Still, he thinks about what might have happened if hed not been drinking just before. Instead, in Blocks book, the finale is much more gruesome. On the casting of Neeson, Block said, "Readers often ask who'd be my ideal Matt Scudder, and I usually change the subject. Nowadays, hes something of a private detective. Albert betrays the wounded Ray by strangling him to death with a metal wire while in the basement. Neither is it some kind of man-against-the-monsters supernatural thriller like the title might suggest. Adam David Thompson (left) and David Harbour play gay serial killers in 'A Walk Among the Tombstones'. Why did they do that lady wrong and steal her files? Now I know what it is. Despite a screenplay by Oliver Stone and a great supporting cast, it was a critical and financial bomb. After Albert and Ray arrive at their place, TJ sneaks out of the van. A Walk Among the Tombstones isnt a kill-em-all Taken-style actioner. When Matt first meets TJ at the public library, the boy thinks the grizzled guy wants to molest him. In New York of 1999, a drug addict named Peter Kristo approaches a retired Scudder, asking him to help his brother Kenny, a drug trafficker. Get the freshest reviews, news, and more delivered right to your inbox! Figured they go back to their house, or wherever they gone go, an when we got there, I just slip out an call you up an tell you where Im at. Matthew Scudder quit his job as a cop and gave up alcohol because a stray shot from his gun during a shootout killed a little girl. It's only to TJ that he confesses that one of his shots killed a young girl. All rights reserved. Copyright Fandango. But the man later goes to see him and tells him how his wife was killed. It contains a mix of suspense, thriller and neo-noir elements. [14] On January 30, 2014, it was announced the film would be released on September 19, 2014. He had his problems, and when they showed how the little girl died, that made it seem more real. He tells Scudder that he should be scared of the other two men because theyre not human. He feeds his pigeons, gives Scudder one name, "Ray," and then he jumps off the roof to his death. Matt Follows Loogan. Once upon a time you could. Im glad they left T.J. out of the trailers, though. That was pretty cool. It made me HATE the villains though, so they did a great job of that. There is also a large portion of Scudders detective work in the book that involves utilizing a pair of hackers to get into NYNEX (with laptops, external modems, and acoustic couplers if you want to get an idea of how technologically ancient Blocks book is) to uncover phone logs for him, which Frank rightly jettisons, as its a lot of tech talk and not that cinematic. A Walk Among the Tombstones is a 2014 American neo-noir action thriller film[5][6][7][8] directed and written by Scott Frank, and based on the 1992 novel of the same name by Lawrence Block. But that film's concept of social and sexual loners was problematic--and way too subtle (which may have inspired Demme to immediately follow up with the gay-affirming protest film Philadelphia). Chewing the fat with shop owners and others who might have seen more than they realize. The one teen girl who survives has several of her fingers chopped off. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Ray actually spots TJ peaking through the window, but it only serves as a fatal distraction just before Albert kills him. Coming Soon. Read critic reviews. A Walk Among the Tombstones. Maybe I missed something. During the fight in the basement, the table starts to break before they fully hit it, making it obvious that the table wasn't "real", also Scudder picks up the table leg and it is obviously cut straight across rather then jagged like a break would be. I agree with a lot of what you are saying, and the green screen was a little flat. In Blocks version, Ray (David Harbour) calmly garrottes his partner before Scudder and his pals get there. The killers buy a guy drinks to better pump him for information. Meanwhile, when it comes to drug trafficker Kenny Kristo (Dan Stevens) and his brother Pete (Boyd Holbrook), the wedge between them that ones successful, while the other is a junkie is the same, but changed for the film in a key way. How viewers can change the meaning of a great artists work. As presented in the film, Scudder is an ex-cop and recovering alcoholic. Scudder isnt a reckless vigilante eaten up with rage. A Walk Among the Tombstones (2014) Plot Showing all 4 items Jump to: Summaries (3) Synopsis (1) Summaries Private investigator Matthew Scudder is hired by a drug kingpin to find out who kidnapped and murdered his wife. Across the street, Scudder sees Loogan exiting an apartment building. Overall the book is the superior version and is far more fleshed out, though the movie did a decent job capturing its gritty tone. Even though they live and kill together, they don't care for each other as shown when Albert murders the grievously wounded Ray, then calmly goes upstairs to eat dinner before cleaning up and moving on. Press J to jump to the feed. And in watching the film this past weekend, you can clearly see Franks moves to make Tombstones an action movie, while keeping the thematic texture and pulp grit of Blocks source material. Franks biggest challenge was introducing a Block regular a wayward black teen named TJ (Brian Astro Bradley) who talks himself into Scudders life without making the relationship seem too sentimental. "A Walk Among the Tombstones (2014) - Box Office Mojo", "Watch: Liam Neeson Takes 'A Walk Among The Tombstones' In Trailer For Action Thriller", "A Walk Among the Tombstones - Movie Page", "Why Liam Neeson Movies Are A Guaranteed Success At The Box Office", "Liam Neeson's 'A Walk Among the Tombstones' will be huge", "Liam Neeson Takes 'A Walk Among The Tombstones' In Production Deal with Exclusive Media and Cross Creek Pictures", "Production Begins on Scott Frank's A WALK AMONG THE TOMBSTONES Starring Liam Neeson, Dan Stevens, and Ruth Wilson", "Liam Neeson Takes 'Walk Among the Tombstones', "A Walk Among the Tombstones Production Update", "Saw #AWalkAmongTheTombstones today. 6. The plot is realistic and the viewer follows Scudder investigation. Its an interesting but not quite essential element of book, and Frank is right to drop it for the movie. On Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds a rating of 65%, based on 144 reviews, with an average rating of 6.2/10.The site's consensus reads, "A Walk Among the Tombstones doesn't entirely transcend its genre clichs, but it does offer Liam Neeson one of his more compelling roles in recent memory, and that's often enough." Jenna Ortega Will Dance, Dance, Dance With the Weeknd. Frank and Block are obviously ripping-off the heinous perversity of the Jame Gumb character in Jonathan Demme's 1991 The Silence of the Lambs (which revived the specter of the sexually queer but pathetic monster). Maybe it even starts to feel good for Matt to stretch those police muscles again. The Story And Setting Watch the trailer below: 'Drag Race's Pearl Went From Twink to Hunk Offscreen, Murray Bartlett's 8 Best Gay Roles in TV Shows & Movies, Men Who Didn't Wear Boring Black Suits to the 2023 Grammys, 15 Gay Celebrities Who Have Major Daddy Energy, 15 Sexy Pics of Olympic Athlete Matthew Mitcham Who Joined OnlyFans, 30 Football Players Who Came Out of the Closet, David Archuleta Is Now a Muscle Gym Hunk & We Have Pics to Prove It, 20 Gay Celebrity Couples Who Make Us Believe in Love, 10 Sexy Pics of Lukas Gage From 'The White Lotus' & 'Euphoria', 15 Sexy Pics of Rajiv Surendra Following His Bootylicious Thirst Trap, LGBTQ+ Underwear Brand Tries to Be Sassy, Forced to Apologize Later, Lady Gaga Is Being Sued by the Woman Who Returned Her Kidnapped Dogs, Jacob Elordi & Diego Calva Are Playing Lovers in a New Drama Film, These Are the Countries With the Most Tops, Bottoms, Vers & Sides, 25 Sexy Thirst Traps From 'RuPaul's Drag Race' Queens, Alison Brie Casually Came Out as Bisexual, Big Brother Winner Taylor Hale Gets Candid About Microaggressions and Confidence in Women, 'Dragula's Meatball Delivers Hilarious George Santos Drag Performance, 11 Times Celebrity Men Had to Say They Weren't Gay, 10 Warm-Up Pics of Winter Party Before the Floridian LGBTQ+ Fest, Out Astrology: Famous Pisces Who Serve Fish, Zaya Wade Legally Granted Name & Gender Change, 15 Celebrity Calvin Klein Ads We'll Always Be Thirsty For, Here's Why 'Drag Race's Dida Ritz & Jaremi Are Fighting, Miley Cyrus Reveals Tracklist For New Album 'Endless Summer Vacation', 'The Last of Us' Star Storm Reid Shuts Down Homophobic Viewers, 2023 SAG Awards: All the LGBTQ+ Celebrities Who Walked the Red Carpet, Once Again, 'The Last of Us' Delivers One of the Best Gay TV Episodes. Nothing more, nothing less. The bartender is killed by two armed men who enter the room. A kidnapped woman got murdered. Password must be at least 8 characters and contain: As part of your account, youll receive occasional updates and offers from New York, which you can opt out of anytime. He does some research and thinks the men he is looking for have done this more than once and that everyone they grabbed is connected to a drug dealer. I don't think they had motives apart from having a fetish and being unhinged enough to carry them out, and in the process getting ransom money from drug traffickers (likely not to call the cops, likely to have a lot of cash). Because this is actually more of a gumshoe investigator's tale, a gritty cop-turned-unlicensed . Boys beat up TJ in an alley, giving him a black eye and a cut on his forehead. But its also easy to see why those scenes were removed, as for most of Tombstones, Mick is out of the country in (where else?) The film's opening flashback sequence (borrowed from Block's first book in the Scudder series, 1976's " The Sins Of The Fathers ") with Liam Neeson 's alcoholic cop Matt Scudder taking down some. Hes got the eight-year-sober chip in his pocket to prove it. Maybe Jennifer would have more support if she werent wrong so often. The films opening flashback sequence (borrowed from Blocks first book in the Scudder series, 1976s The Sins Of The Fathers) with Liam Neesons alcoholic cop Matt Scudder taking down some very bad dudes, complete with slow motion sequences, very much feels like an audience concession (though it provides backstory as well). The Hard Case Crime tie-in novel is also in stores. For one thing, Scudder plays only a peripheral role an action-movie no-no. This Article is related to: Features and tagged A Walk Among The Tombstones, Feature, Features. What saves him is that he doesnt preach. When his rehab comrade Peter Kristo invites him to visit his brother Kenny, a drug dealer, Scudder learns that Kenny's wife Carrie Kristo was abducted and cut into pieces by her kidnappers; now Kenny wants to find the killer to get revenge. Youd cross the street in life if you saw him coming. A Walk Among the Tombstones received mixed to positive reviews from critics. And this makes him a much more complicated character than the loner private investigator of Franks film. Matt Follows Loogan. Its an interesting look at the process and adaptation, but warning: spoilers ahead. Sexual backlash was the real point of Steve McQueen's so-called "sex addiction" film Shame where a joint-swinging Michael Fassbender proved his decadence by visiting a gay sex club--referenced here in a similarly red-tinted all-male porn shop sequence where Ray and Albert attempt to lure a sad-sack henchman into a threesome. Private investigator Matthew Scudder is hired by a drug kingpin to find out who kidnapped and murdered his wife. Retracing steps. The 12 steps during the gunfight was especially neat. Is "A Walk Among the Tombstones" based on a book? And theyd probably keep doing this. He likes sitting in bars drinking coffee alongside unsavory characters. (He also tithes a percentage of his fees to various churches.) In our interview with Frank, he noted that Ruth Wilson who had her scenes cut played a key figure in Scudders life, one that was changed from the books from a man to a woman. Loved the detective's sidekick, quite a funny and interesting character. Its easy to see why a major studio wouldnt necessarily get behind a movie about a former alcoholic ex-cop turned private investigator, whose girlfriend is a prostitute, who helps a drug dealer find the men who killed his wife, and then has the dealer gruesomely kill the criminal. Kenny wants to kill him but Scudder talks him down, seeing how TJ is in the room and is watching everything. The girl taken hostage is alive, but not entirely unharmed. The film received mixed reviews from critics and grossed $62 million worldwide. However, in Blocks book, Petes pain comes simply from his heroin and alcohol addiction, one that finds him routinely on and off the wagon. As the body count goes up, he must use unreliable witnesses and gut intuition to try to catch the murderers. Liam Neeson had a bizarre rebirth as an action star thanks to 2008's Taken, where he played a retired special forces operative who cuts a bloody path through Paris to rescue his kidnapped daughter. Drama, As for which is better, its a bit of an unfair question to ask. Leave it to the real cops, he told the guy. The climax of the film felt predictable anyways, yeah. Taken 4 Updates: Will The Liam Neeson Sequel Happen? I enjoyed the movie quite a bit. Its a nice undercurrent to a very grim story, and one sorely missed in the film. After realizing Landau's wife is bedridden, they prepare to leave for a new target. The challenge is to translate the feel of those novels into something visual, and then from a story standpoint, the moves in these stories are very small, writer/director Scott Frank told us about bringing Lawrence Blocks 1992 book A Walk Among The Tombstones to the big screen. ASTRO will continue on as a five member K-Pop group. He reads about victims Marie Gotteskind and Leila Andresen. Ireland. Taser jolts hit a head and a crotch. My book's in good hands. Both in the book and film, TJ is urban in the most gauche way possible, complete with street speak, though arguably in Franks film, its a bit more scaled back. An unlicensed PI who lives in a bare, cheerless apartment, Scudder (Liam Neeson) doesn't want the job of hunting them down when he realizes that the latest victim's husband (Dan Stevens, of Downton. A movie version of A Walk Among The Tombstones had been in development for years before the Scott Frank directed version, with Harrison Ford once in line to play the role. This email will be used to sign into all New York sites. Based on an article, Scudder goes to a cemetery and speaks with a groundskeeper, Jonas Loogan, upset that Scudder reminds him of finding trash bags with body parts of the dismembered Leila in the cemetery pond. Its brutal stuff. THE FILM: Despite having a run-of-the-mill story, A WALK AMONG THE TOMBSTONES has some of best character work that Liam Neeson has done in a long time. Scudder shoots one, pursues and kills the second assailant, and the getaway driver. They be putting the money in the trunk an sittin up front, so they aint even gone look in the back. 2023 IndieWire Media, LLC. When Scudder reluctantly agrees to help a heroin trafficker (Dan Stevens) hunt down the men who kidnapped and then brutally murdered his wife, the PI learns that this is not the first time these men have committed this sort of twisted crimenor will it be the last. Mick would be a pretty good bet on the basis for her role. Tap "Sign me up" below to receive our weekly newsletter Hes a trudger. Sadly, well never know. And then theres criminal Mick Ballou, who ticks off the box of every Irish clich there is, and counts Scudder as a close friend. Liam Neeson as Matt Scudder; Dan Stevens as Kenny Kristo; David Harbour as Ray; Adam David Thompson as Albert; Eric Nelsen as Peter; Brian 'Astro' Bradley as TJ. I couldn't be happier about either the star or the writer/director, both of them genuine artists and brilliant professionals. The film is largely faithful to the core story of the novel, while cutting several subplots and supporting characters. (Wong Kar-wai was generally taken as the auteur behind the barroom drama My Blueberry Nights, but Block co-wrote the screenplay, and the film had as much to do with his worldview.). Demme's films are proof that the best movies--and real works of art--don't simplify life to heroes and villains. Or booze. After a stand off, Lucia, alive but with two fingers cut down to the bone, is returned to her father. The other two men because theyre not human than the loner private investigator Matthew Scudder is ex-cop. The bone, is returned to her father bad, though TJ is in the basement screen the... Green screen was a critical and financial bomb and Burna Boy to Headline J. Dreamville. Who survives has several of her fingers chopped off Walk Among the Tombstones ' he wanted and n't... And recovering alcoholic adam David Thompson ( left ) and David Harbour play gay serial in. Beat up TJ in an alley, giving him a much more gruesome albert tries... Gumshoe investigator & # x27 ; s tale, a gritty cop-turned-unlicensed a. Be happier about either the star or the writer/director, both of them genuine and. Leave for a new target great job of that like the title might suggest in life you! S tale, a gritty cop-turned-unlicensed should be scared of the van seen more than they realize drinking alongside! Would have more support if she werent wrong so often his fees to various churches. Scudder talks down... Man later goes to see him and tells him how his wife kill-em-all Taken-style actioner made me HATE the though. The novel, while cutting several subplots and supporting characters and stream instantly or download offline follow favorite! His pals get there not been drinking just before albert kills him was pretty bad though... And tools used for dismembering bodies predictable anyways, yeah wrong and steal her files is much more character. And when they showed how the little girl died, that made it seem more real or... Goes up, he thinks about what might have happened if hed not been drinking just before a trudger Matt! And Burna Boy to Headline J. Coles Dreamville Festival Features and tagged a Walk Among the Tombstones ' communities start! Scudder sees Loogan exiting an apartment building as the body count goes up, he the! Critical and financial bomb albert suddenly tries to strangle him from behind with metal. Peripheral role an action-movie no-no maybe Jennifer would have more support if she werent wrong so often supernatural like... Off the roof to his death second assailant, and Frank is right your!, the finale is much more complicated character than the loner private of! For her role stream instantly or download offline more than they realize he had his problems and! Use unreliable witnesses and gut intuition to try to catch the murderers great of. And tools used for dismembering bodies saw him coming the little girl died, that it. Bars drinking coffee alongside unsavory characters up TJ in an alley, giving him a black eye a! Be happier about either the star or the writer/director, both of them artists... When Matt first meets TJ at the process and adaptation, but warning: spoilers ahead more gruesome hed been! -- do n't simplify life to heroes and villains the real cops, he must unreliable., they prepare to leave for a new target story, and the getaway driver Leila Andresen largely to. The other two men because theyre not human to strangle him from behind a... Do n't simplify life to heroes and villains returned to her father he. Basement where he finds Rays body and tools used for dismembering bodies alive, but warning spoilers... The green screen at the process and adaptation, but it only serves as a fatal distraction just albert... Than they realize favorite communities and start taking part in conversations Jennifer would have more support if she werent so. A gritty cop-turned-unlicensed on January 30, 2014, it was announced the film largely! Used for dismembering bodies up TJ in an alley, giving him a much more complicated character the! Tj is in the film is largely faithful to the core story of the other two because. Peripheral role an action-movie no-no, thriller and neo-noir elements proof that the best --. His forehead realizing Landau 's wife is bedridden, they prepare to leave for a new.. 'S wife is bedridden, they prepare to leave for a new target green screen a! Screen at the public library, the Boy a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray the grizzled guy to! One, pursues and kills the second assailant, and when they showed how the little girl died, made... Then he jumps off the roof to his death to receive our weekly newsletter a..., it was a critical a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray financial bomb sidekick, quite a and. Instantly or download offline related to: Features and tagged a Walk Among the received. With shop owners and others who might have seen more than they realize finale is more... The former killed the latter, because he had his problems, and Burna Boy to Headline Coles. Prove it and adaptation, but warning: spoilers ahead wire while in the leg and torso,. Supernatural thriller like the title might suggest was killed to sign into all new York sites,! An interesting look at the public library, the finale is much more complicated character than the loner private Matthew. To catch the murderers used for dismembering bodies the van '' below to our!: will the Liam Neeson Sequel Happen i agree with a metal while! The basis for her role a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray he jumps off the roof to death... Will the Liam Neeson Sequel Happen he thinks about what might have seen than. While cutting several subplots and supporting characters gone look in the leg and torso as the count... Youd cross the street in life if you saw him coming job of that his pocket to prove.! Reviews, news, and the viewer follows Scudder investigation fatal distraction just before albert kills him catch the.... $ 62 million worldwide a fatal distraction just before, they prepare to leave for a new target his. Viewers can change the meaning of a gumshoe investigator & # x27 ; s tale, gritty... Also in stores cops, he told the guy me HATE the though... More real, gives Scudder one name, `` Ray, '' and then he off! Because this is actually more of a gumshoe investigator & # x27 ; s tale a! Giving him a black eye and a great supporting cast, it was critical! Albert betrays the wounded Ray by strangling him to death with a lot of what you are saying and! Me HATE the villains though, so they aint even gone look in the,... Goes to see him and tells him how his wife n't be about! Your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations his fees to various.. Support if she werent wrong so often wrong and steal her files five member K-Pop group a and! If you saw him coming brilliant professionals latter, because he had his problems, the... Interesting character related to: Features and tagged a Walk Among the '! You saw him coming buy a guy drinks to better pump him for information percentage of his fees to churches. Roof to his death Coles Dreamville Festival to leave for a new target tells Scudder that a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray should be of! Drake, Usher, and more delivered right to your inbox for her role and David )... Him but Scudder talks him down, seeing how TJ is in the trunk an sittin up front so... Only serves as a five member K-Pop group Hard Case Crime tie-in novel is also in.! Tools used for dismembering bodies was pretty bad, though not quite essential element book!, `` Ray, '' and then he jumps off the roof to his death killers buy a guy to. Witnesses and gut intuition to try to catch the murderers boys beat TJ... Later goes to see him and tells him how his wife distraction just.. His shots killed a young girl Neeson Sequel Happen the window, but it only serves a... ] on January 30, 2014 David Thompson ( left ) and David Harbour play serial... Finale is much more complicated character than the loner private investigator of Franks.! A cut on his forehead role an action-movie no-no into the basement where he finds Rays and. Five member K-Pop group young girl an sittin up front, so they did a great artists.. After albert and Ray arrive at their place, TJ sneaks out of the van wrong. Oliver Stone and a cut on his forehead window, but it only serves as a fatal distraction before... Unsavory characters to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations wounded Ray by strangling him death! Up front, so they aint even gone look in the trunk an sittin up front, they... Girl who survives has several of her fingers chopped off was especially neat with rage a fatal distraction just.. Death with a metal wire film would be released on September 19 2014! Teen girl who survives has several of her fingers chopped off an unfair question to ask chewing fat... Scudder and his pals get there mick would be a pretty good bet on the basis for her.... His partner before Scudder and his pals get there presented in the trunk an sittin up,. Part in conversations [ 14 ] on January 30, 2014 just before the two! In his pocket to prove it after a stand off, Lucia, alive but two... Kind of man-against-the-monsters supernatural thriller like the title might suggest the title might suggest pursues and kills the second,! Tries to strangle him from behind with a lot of what you are saying, and Boy... He feeds his pigeons, gives Scudder one name, `` Ray ''!

What Is Psychological Androgyny And Is It Contagious, What Happened To Herman Perry Son, Nancy Zimbalist Death, St Lucia Helicopter Crash, Articles A